SMS Carrier Fines and Non-Compliance Fees: What a Small Business Can Actually Be Charged

T-Mobile's non-compliance fees run from $500 to $10,000 per instance, passed through by messaging providers. The TCPA adds $500 per violation, up to triple for willful ones. Here is what triggers each and how to avoid them.

November 17, 20269 min readBy Connor Gallic

There are two separate kinds of money at risk when business texting goes wrong. The first is carrier fees: T-Mobile charges $500 to $2,000 per content violation, $1,000 for evading the program (such as snowshoeing), and $10,000 per instance once violations repeat. The second is the TCPA: a consumer can sue for $500 per violation, and a court can triple that for willful ones. Carrier fees reach you because your messaging provider passes them through. TCPA damages come from a lawsuit.

Neither is common for a business that texts its own callers back about their own requests. Both are very real for one that buys lists, rotates numbers, or sends promotions without clear consent.

This is not legal advice. Carriers do not publish their fee schedules openly. Every carrier figure below is quoted from a messaging provider that passes those fees through, with a link to its page.


Table of Contents

  1. Why the figures come from providers
  2. T-Mobile content violation fees
  3. Program evasion: the snowshoeing fee
  4. Repeat violations: $10,000 per instance
  5. AT&T and Verizon
  6. TCPA statutory damages
  7. How to avoid each one
  8. How KaiCalls handles it
  9. FAQ

Why the figures come from providers

When you text through a phone system, your messages travel through a provider to the carrier. If T-Mobile finds a violation, it charges the provider. The provider then charges the business whose traffic caused it. That is a "pass-through" fee.

Because carriers keep their codes of conduct private, the only public record of these fees is in provider help centers: Bandwidth, Vonage, Sinch, Commio, and Textel. Where several of them agree, the figure is solid. Where only one says it, we say so.

T-Mobile content violation fees

T-Mobile calls its most serious content violations "Sev-0." Bandwidth's T-Mobile 10DLC page lists three tiers:

Tier What it covers Fee per instance
Tier 1 Phishing, smishing, and social engineering $2,000
Tier 2 Illegal content $1,000
Tier 3 Violations $500

Vonage's notice gives the same three figures and describes Tier 3 as "all other violations (including, but not limited to SHAFT)." It says "Those new fines will start being applied from January 1st, 2024."

Two terms worth knowing:

  • SHAFT stands for "Sex, Hate, Alcohol, Firearms, Tobacco." It comes from CTIA's Short Code Monitoring Handbook, which flags "Content that contains or promotes sex, hate, alcohol, firearms, or tobacco." A bar texting a drink special is in this territory. CTIA's 2023 Messaging Principles (Section 5.3.1) also lists content that "does not meet age-gating requirements" among the things senders should prevent.
  • Illegal content is defined strictly. According to Textel, T-Mobile requires that "content must be legal federally and in all 50 states." Something legal in your state but not federally can still count.

For most service businesses, none of this comes up. Appointment confirmations and "sorry we missed your call" texts are not SHAFT, not phishing, and not illegal.

Program evasion: the snowshoeing fee

This one is separate from content. It is about how you send, not what you say.

Bandwidth lists "A $1,000 pass-through fee if a program is found to be using techniques such as snowshoeing." Sinch's 10DLC FAQ spells out the category: "Program Evasion: $1,000 USD for each unique instance of a violation (snowshoeing, dynamic routing, spam filter evasion, unapproved campaign service)." Commio says the same: "T-Mobile has specific penalties ($1,000 per instance) around program evasion of the 10DLC program."

What triggers it: spreading similar messages across many numbers to get past filters or limits, swapping numbers to dodge spam filters, or sending traffic that does not match an approved campaign. The full explanation is in What Is Snowshoeing in Business Texting?

Repeat violations: $10,000 per instance

Fees grow when problems repeat. Bandwidth lists "A $10,000 pass-through fee for each unique instance of the third or any subsequent notification." In plain terms: after two warnings, each further violation costs $10,000.

That is the number that can sink a small business. It is also the easiest to avoid. A sender who fixes the problem after the first notice never gets there.

AT&T and Verizon

AT&T takes a different approach. Twilio's carrier penalties page says "no per-message carrier fines will be charged" for unregistered 10DLC traffic on AT&T. Instead, the traffic is blocked. Twilio says unregistered 10DLC messages to US recipients are blocked with error 30034. (That is an older support page, but the blocking is the point.)

We did not find a published AT&T or Verizon fee schedule like T-Mobile's. If you see a specific AT&T or Verizon fine figure quoted online, ask where it came from.

Blocking is its own cost. A blocked text is a customer who thinks you never got back to them. If that is happening, the 10DLC troubleshooting guide walks through the causes.

TCPA statutory damages

Carrier fees are contract terms between companies. The Telephone Consumer Protection Act is federal law, and it lets consumers sue.

The statute, 47 U.S.C. 227, covers calls made "using any automatic telephone dialing system or an artificial or prerecorded voice" to cell phone numbers, unless made "with the prior express consent of the called party." Under 227(b)(3), a person can sue "to receive $500 in damages for each such violation." If the violation was willful or knowing, "the court may, in its discretion, increase the amount of the award to an amount equal to not more than 3 times" that amount. That is where the familiar "$500 to $1,500 per message" figure comes from.

The FCC's consent rules, in 47 CFR 64.1200, speak of consent "to receive calls or text messages," so texts are part of the picture. The FCC has also codified that the National Do-Not-Call Registry's protections extend to text messages, in FCC 23-107.

What triggers TCPA claims, in plain terms: texting people who never agreed to hear from you, ignoring a STOP or other clear request to stop, and sending marketing without the right consent. The consent rules are in SMS Consent Rules. For where KaiCalls' tools end and your decisions begin, see How KaiCalls Handles TCPA, Do Not Call, and A2P Compliance.

How to avoid each one

Risk What triggers it How to avoid it
T-Mobile content fee ($500 to $2,000) Phishing-like messages, SHAFT content, illegal content Text only about your own business. Use full links on your domain. Keep sales language off service campaigns.
Program evasion fee ($1,000) Snowshoeing, rotating numbers, traffic outside your campaign Register every number. Text each customer from one number.
Repeat fee ($10,000) A third or later notice Fix the cause after the first notice, not the third.
AT&T blocking Unregistered 10DLC traffic Register your brand and campaign, and attach the number to the campaign.
TCPA damages ($500, up to triple) No consent, ignored opt-outs Text only people who asked. Honor STOP right away. Keep records.

Most of this comes down to three habits. Register. Text only people who said yes. Stop when they say stop. The A2P 10DLC guide covers the registration side.

How KaiCalls handles it

KaiCalls is a business phone line, with Kai as your secretary. The texting rules that keep fees and lawsuits away are gates in the sending code, not tips on a policy page.

  • Registration handled for you. When your business files its own brand and campaign, KaiCalls prepares the filing, checks it for common rejection reasons first, and files it. Kai's texts go out under an approved registration.
  • Content screen. Kai blocks marketing language on service texts, URL shorteners, messages over 1,600 characters, and messages that are mostly capital letters.
  • Consent check. No consent record, no text. Sales texts need a separate marketing opt-in.
  • STOP and Do Not Call block. A number that replied STOP, or is on your Do Not Call list, is blocked. STOP always wins.
  • Quiet hours. Texts between 9 PM and 8 AM in the person's local time are held until morning.
  • Daily caps. A daily cap per business and a per-person limit stop bursts.
  • Reply keywords work on every number, and the opt-out is saved before the confirmation goes out.

The tools lower the chance of a mistake and keep a record. Who your business contacts is still your call. Details: How KaiCalls Handles A2P 10DLC Registration and the 10DLC registration overview.

FAQ

How much does T-Mobile fine for non-compliant texts? According to providers that pass the fees through, T-Mobile charges $2,000 for phishing, smishing, and social engineering, $1,000 for illegal content, and $500 for other content violations. It also charges $1,000 for program evasion such as snowshoeing and $10,000 per instance from the third notice on for repeat violations.

Does AT&T fine businesses for unregistered texts? Not per message, according to Twilio's carrier penalties page. AT&T blocks unregistered 10DLC traffic instead. We did not find a published AT&T or Verizon fee schedule like T-Mobile's.

What are TCPA damages for texts? The TCPA lets a consumer sue for $500 per violation of its autodialer and prerecorded-voice rules, and a court can raise that to as much as three times the amount for willful or knowing violations. The FCC's consent rules apply to calls and text messages.

Who pays a carrier fine, me or my provider? Carriers charge the messaging provider, and providers pass the fee through to the customer whose traffic caused it. That is why the published figures come from provider help pages, not from carriers.


Want texting that stays inside the lines? Read the 10DLC registration overview, or call the KaiCalls demo line at (417) 835-0402, hang up before Kai answers, and watch the follow-up text arrive.

Topics

t-mobile sms finessms carrier fines10dlc non-compliance feest-mobile sev-0 finestcpa text message fines

Want Kai to answer when you can't?

When you can't pick up, Kai answers, takes the details and saves the conversation. Hear it on your own business first.

$2 for your first week, then from $10/mo. Cancel anytime. See plans

Explore call answering options